Selling to Old Pueblo Coin

Should I clean my coins?

No! Don’t clean your coins! Most collectors prefer original, uncleaned coins. Cleaning can damage coins, lower their value, and cannot be undone. We can properly determine the value of coins even if they look dirty or dark.

Should I have my collection sorted before selling?

There is no need for you to spend a lot of time sorting your items; we will be sorting them anyway.

Should I make an inventory list of my coins before selling?

If you are planning to sell, making a full inventory list is not worth the time for most collections (for example, making an inventory of common-date circulated wheat cents would be a waste of time, since we buy them all at the same price).

Is there a charge to get my items appraised / evaluated?

Verbal appraisals are free, and there is no obligation to sell to us. If you need a professional appraisal for estate, insurance, or legal purposes, please see our page on written appraisals.

Do I need to make an appointment ahead of time?

Appointments are not necessary, but are preferred if you have more than a shoebox full of coins. Walk-ins with no prior appointment are welcome. For larger collections, please arrive at least an hour before closing time. If you prefer to make an appointment or have any questions, feel free to call us (Please note that there may be a brief waiting period when our store is very busy).

I am not a local customer, can I still sell to Old Pueblo Coin?

If you have interest in selling to us but are not near us, you can send an email with a few photos and a description of the items available to staff@oldpueblocoin.com

Buying from Old Pueblo Coin (online)

How long does shipping take?

Most orders ship within 1 business day of funds clearing. Orders usually arrive within 3-5 business days from shipping date, depending on the destination (shipping delays may occur that are outside our control).

How will my coins be shipped?

Your order will be shipped safely and securely in discreet packaging with no mention of value or contents or use of the word “coin” (the return address shows our name as “Old Pueblo C.”). We ship hundreds of packages each month and our shippers have experience shipping 10,000+ packages.

What shipping carrier do you use?

Orders may be shipped USPS First Class Package, USPS Priority Mail, or USPS Registered Mail at our discretion depending on various factors such as size, weight, and value. Some orders may require signature confirmation.

Does Old Pueblo Coin ship internationally?

We only ship domestically in the United States at this time.